Hidden gems in Times Square: 5 unique things to do in Midtown
Uncover unique things to do in Midtown and local spots near Times Square — from secret gardens to authentic bars and creative spaces.
** Edited by Kaitlyn Dreyling | October 24, 2025**
Times Square dazzles with neon lights and Broadway shows, yet its true magic lies just beyond the main drag. For travelers craving a deeper connection to Midtown Manhattan, these hidden gems — urban parks, quirky landmarks, and beloved local haunts — offer a refreshing escape from the crowds and a chance to experience the city like a true New Yorker. Whether you’re searching for secret places in Times Square or unique things to do in Midtown, you’re sure to have a memorable visit in New York City when you venture off the beaten path.
1. Paley Park: A tranquil retreat
Just a short walk from the energy of Times Square, Paley Park feels worlds away from the city’s constant buzz. This intimate urban oasis features a lush canopy of trees, ivy-draped walls, and a dramatic waterfall that muffles the city’s noise with a gentle, restorative hush. Locals slip away here for a quiet coffee, a midday break, or simply to recharge amid the soothing greenery. The park’s compact size and tucked-away location make it a favorite hidden gem for those in the know.
After unwinding at Paley Park, guests can return to Hilton New York Times Square, where the Sky Lobby’s sweeping views and artful design offer a serene perspective on Midtown. With guest rooms perched high above the city, a concierge, and a 15th-floor bar and lounge, this hotel is an ideal starting point for discovering Times Square’s secret spaces.
2. The Morgan Library & Museum: A Gilded Age marvel
Tucked along Madison Avenue, The Morgan Library & Museum invites you into the opulent world of financier J.P. Morgan’s private collection. The main library room, with its soaring shelves and ornate ceilings, feels like a portal to another era — quiet, gilded, and awe-inspiring. Home to rare manuscripts and three copies of the Gutenberg Bible, this serene venue offers hidden alcoves and rotating exhibitions for quiet reflection. This sophisticated retreat is a true hidden gem for culture lovers, just a short walk from the Empire State Building.
Stay nearby at Hilton Garden Inn New York/Manhattan-Midtown East, where Grand Central’s energy and Midtown’s secret parks are right at your doorstep. Modern guest rooms provide a restful haven after a day of exploration while on-site dining at The Garden Grille & Bar offers an added touch of convenience. Confirmed Connecting Rooms by Hilton™ also make it easy to travel as a family or with a group.
3. Jimmy’s Corner: A true local haunt
Step out of the bright lights of Times Square and into Jimmy’s Corner, a beloved bar layered with boxing history and New York grit. Founded by the late Jimmy Glenn, a legendary boxer and trainer, its walls are lined with memorabilia and photos, creating a living museum of the city’s fight culture. The bar’s unpretentious, welcoming vibe is an antidote to Midtown’s glitz, drawing locals and travelers alike for affordable drinks and authentic conversations. After a night at Jimmy’s, unwind at Hampton Inn by Hilton New York Times Square, where free hot breakfast and a central location make it easy to explore Midtown’s hidden gems from sunrise to last call.
4. The Drama Book Shop: Broadway’s best-kept secret
The Drama Book Shop is a haven for theater lovers and Broadway insiders alike. Purchased by Lin-Manuel Miranda and a group of passionate creatives in 2019, this cozy shop is filled with plays, scripts, and theatrical treasures. Its inviting nooks and whimsical décor make it a peaceful spot to browse or catch a reading, not far from the lights of Broadway.
For guests inspired by the city’s creative spirit, Hilton Garden Inn New York/Times Square Central offers modern amenities and a location that puts you near the Theater District, making every show night or book-browsing session a breeze. The recently renovated space is conveniently located a few steps away from three subway stations and offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner at Paul's on Times Square.
5. The Church of Saint Mary the Virgin: A gothic sanctuary
Hidden in plain sight on West 46th Street, The Church of Saint Mary the Virgin is a soaring Gothic Revival sanctuary that will transport you to another world. Step inside to discover stained glass windows, vaulted ceilings, and a profound sense of calm — a dramatic contrast to the Theater District’s energy just outside. The church’s serene interior is a favorite cool-down spot for those seeking beauty and stillness in Midtown.
When you’re ready to rejoin hustle and bustle of the city, New York Hilton Midtown is just a short walk away, offering panoramic city views and a restful retreat from the action. It features spacious guestrooms and suites with views of the city skyline, plus creative cocktails at Bridges Bar and a 24-hour fitness center.
Disclaimer: We used AI assistance to generate this content. All information was reviewed by Hilton's team to ensure it meets our standards for accuracy and ethics, allowing us to better match your travel needs and connect you with the right stay.
Explore more in New York
Waldorf Astoria New York: The true powerhouse
The iconic hotel, once the largest luxury hotel in the world, is ready to welcome guests again after an extensive restoration that blends history with sophisticated, modern details.
The best hotels in New York City for exploring it all
Whether it’s exciting entertainment or class and culture, these are the best hotels in New York City for the trip of a lifetime.
A fashion lover’s getaway to New York City
From iconic boutiques to the famed Fashion Week, New York has long been synonymous with high fashion.
Experience an iconic urban escape in New York City
Discover the ultimate indulgence in New York City with unique culinary gems, world-class experiences, and relaxing opportunities for rejuvenation while staying at The Greatest of Them All, Waldorf Astoria New York.
Read more:
Find travel inspiration